Ways Awkward Introverts Can Succeed at Talking to Strangers

Talking to strangers doesn't have to be overwhelming, but often small talk is highly stressful.In the intricate tapestry of human interaction, the art of conversation is often seen as the thread that weaves relationships together. For many individuals on the autism spectrum, however, this thread of back-and-forth speaking and even choosing random questions to ask or talking to strangers can feel tangled and complex. 

This can present unique challenges in both initiating conversations and maintaining small talk.

This struggle, while not universal to all autistic individuals, is a common experience that can significantly impact various aspects of life, from forming and keeping friendships to succeeding in work environments.

Understanding Autism and Social Communication Disorder

Before exploring the specific challenges, it’s crucial to understand that autism is a neurodevelopmental condition characterized by differences in social communication, sensory processing, and patterns of behavior or interests.

While many autistics have a social communication disorder, this is far from universal. The autism spectrum is vast and diverse, with each individual experiencing a unique combination of strengths and challenges.

When it comes to human interaction, many autistics may experience:

  • Difficulty interpreting nonverbal cues
  • Challenges in understanding and using figurative language
  • A tendency toward the literal interpretation of speech
  • Differences in the rhythm, stress, and intonation of speech
  • Difficulty in understanding unwritten social rules and expectations
  • Awkwardness in talking to strangers
  • Inability to make small talk
  • Looping on a particular thought, topic, or interest

These differences can make the seemingly simple act of starting and maintaining a conversation a complex and often anxiety-inducing process.

The Challenges of Initiating Conversations

For many autistics, the first hurdle in human interaction is simply knowing how and when to start a conversation. This difficulty can stem from several factors:

  1. Social Anxiety: The fear of potential rejection or misunderstanding can be paralyzing. Many autistic individuals report feeling intense anxiety about approaching others or talking to strangers, worried they might say the wrong thing or be perceived as odd or intrusive.
  1. Difficulty Reading Social Cues: Neurotypical individuals often rely on subtle nonverbal signals to indicate openness to conversation. These might include making eye contact, smiling, or adopting an open posture. For autistic individuals who may struggle to interpret these cues, it can be challenging to recognize when someone is approachable or interested in talking.
  1. Uncertainty About Topics: Deciding what to talk about can be another significant hurdle. While many autistic individuals have deep knowledge and passion for specific subjects, they may worry about whether these topics will interest others or be appropriate for casual conversation.
  1. Scripting and Spontaneity: Some autistic individuals rely on learned scripts or pre-planned conversation starters, such as random questions to ask. While these can be helpful, they may struggle when the conversation deviates from expected patterns, making it difficult to adapt to the natural flow of spontaneous interaction.
  1. Sensory Overload: In busy or noisy environments, sensory input can be overwhelming for autistic individuals. This sensory overload can make it even more challenging to focus on the complex task of initiating social interaction.

The Struggle to Maintain Small Talk and Human Interaction

Small talk can be a huge challenge, and deciding random questions to ask even more so.Once a conversation has begun, many autistic individuals face ongoing challenges in keeping the interaction flowing smoothly. These difficulties can include:

  • Turn-taking: The back-and-forth rhythm of conversation can be challenging to navigate. Some autistic individuals may struggle with knowing when it’s their turn to speak or may inadvertently interrupt others.
  • Topic Maintenance: While passionate about certain subjects, autistic individuals may find it difficult to gauge when others are losing interest or to shift topics gracefully. This can lead to one-sided conversations or abrupt changes in subject matter. Many autistics start thinking of random questions to ask to keep a topic going, but may not associate that they don’t necessarily cause a degree of enthusiasm and response by the other individuals they are speaking with.
  • Reciprocal Sharing: Conversations typically involve a mutual exchange of information and experiences. Some autistic individuals may struggle with asking follow-up questions or sharing related personal anecdotes, which can make the interaction feel unbalanced.
  • Understanding Subtext: Much of human communication relies on implied meanings and context. Autistic individuals who tend towards literal interpretation may miss subtle hints, sarcasm, or indirect requests, leading to misunderstandings.
  • Processing Speed: Some autistic individuals may need more time to process verbal information and formulate responses. In rapid-fire conversations, this can lead to feelings of being left behind or unable to contribute fully.
  • Emotional Regulation: The intense focus required for social interaction can be emotionally draining. Managing feelings of frustration, anxiety, or overstimulation while trying to maintain a conversation can be extremely challenging.
  • Eye Contact: While preferences vary, many autistic individuals find sustained eye contact uncomfortable or distracting. However, in many cultures, eye contact is considered crucial for engaged conversation, creating a potential source of tension or misunderstanding.

The Impact on Daily Life With A Social Communication Disorder

The challenges associated with initiating and maintaining conversations can have far-reaching effects on an autistic individual’s life:

  • Social Isolation: Difficulty in social communication can lead to fewer friendships and a smaller social network, potentially resulting in feelings of loneliness and isolation.
  • Academic Challenges: In educational settings, group work, class discussions, and presentations all rely heavily on conversational skills. Struggles in these areas can impact academic performance and peer relationships.
  • Professional Implications: Many jobs require strong communication skills. Difficulties in this area can affect job interviews, workplace relationships, and career advancement opportunities, especially when there is a reluctance in talking to strangers.

  • Mental Health: The stress and anxiety associated with social interactions can contribute to mental health challenges such as depression and anxiety disorders.
  • Self-Esteem: Repeated difficulties or perceived failures in social situations can negatively impact self-esteem and self-perception.

Strategies for Improvement In Talking to Strangers and Maintaining Small Talk

Having a social communication disorder doesn't mean you can't learn to navigate the art of talking to strangers or utilizing small talk. You may just have a greater challenge to overcome.While these challenges are significant, there are numerous strategies that autistic individuals and their supporters can employ to improve conversational skills:

  • Practice and Preparation: Rehearsing common social scenarios and developing a repertoire of conversation starters can boost confidence. This might include preparing a list of current events or general interest topics to discuss.
  • Leveraging Special Interests: Finding ways to connect special interests to broader topics can provide natural conversation starters and help sustain engagement in discussions.
  • Using Technology: Text-based communication, social media, and online forums can provide alternative avenues for social interaction that may feel more comfortable and manageable.
  • Mindfulness and Relaxation Techniques: Learning strategies to manage anxiety and sensory overload can make social interactions less stressful and more enjoyable.
  • Social Stories and Visual Supports: These tools can help autistic individuals understand and prepare for various social situations, including conversation norms and expectations.
  • Peer Mentoring: Pairing autistic individuals with neurotypical or autistic peers who have strong social skills can provide opportunities for modeling and practice in natural settings.
  • Self-Advocacy: Learning to communicate one’s needs, preferences, and challenges can help create more supportive and understanding social environments.

The Role of Autistic Voices

In addressing the challenges of conversation and social interaction, it’s essential to center the voices and experiences of autistic individuals themselves. Many autistic self-advocates emphasize the importance of recognizing and valuing diverse communication styles rather than trying to force conformity to neurotypical norms.

Some key points raised by autistic advocates include:

  1. The value of autistic-led support groups and mentoring programs
  2. The importance of presuming competence and not underestimating the abilities of non-speaking autistic individuals
  3. The need for society to broaden its understanding of what constitutes meaningful social interaction
  4. The potential benefits of embracing autistic communication styles, such as directness and depth of focus on specific topics

Reddit users have discussed some of their communication challenges. Reddit user u/Namerakable commented about it on this autism communications struggle thread,  saying, “I can have a conversation with people, but I do have times where people ask me to repeat things because they didn’t understand, or my sentences start to get a bit jumbled. … I interrupt and stammer quite a lot when I’m getting bored.”

u/Psychological_Pair56 wrote, “I’ve masked most of my life so I am usually able to follow regular conversational scripts (I do often practice them when I’m alone). I dislike talking about my interests with people who aren’t equally excited so I tend to listen and ask questions instead. I am awkward but I have developed mechanics for distracting from this.”

In addition, u/capaldis commented about turn-taking challenges, stating that “I can have trouble knowing what a ‘normal’ back and forth is and can really monopolize conversations.”

The Double Empathy Problem with Small Talk and Random Questions to Ask

Small talk can be overwhelming for some but choosing random questions to ask when talking to strangers can help.Recent research has highlighted what’s known as the “double empathy problem” in autism. This concept suggests that the communication difficulties and maintaining small talk between autistic and non-autistic individuals are bidirectional, rather than being solely the result of autistic deficits. Key points include:

  • Mutual Misunderstanding: Non-autistic individuals often struggle to understand and empathize with autistic perspectives just as much as autistic individuals struggle with neurotypical social norms.
  • Different Social Expectations: Autistic and non-autistic individuals may have fundamentally different expectations and preferences for social interaction, leading to mutual confusion.
  • Autistic-to-Autistic Communication: Studies have shown that autistic individuals often communicate more effectively with each other than with non-autistic individuals, suggesting that the issue lies in cross-neurotype understanding rather than inherent communication deficits.
  • Need for Adaptation: This perspective emphasizes the importance of both autistic and non-autistic individuals adapting and learning to bridge the communication gap.

Technology and Autism Social Communication Disorder

Advancements in technology are opening new avenues for autistic communication:

  • Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC): From simple picture boards to sophisticated speech-generating devices, AAC can provide crucial support for non-speaking or minimally speaking autistic individuals.
  • Social Media and Online Communities: These platforms can offer lower-pressure environments for social interaction and opportunities to connect with like-minded individuals.

(Please check out my growing Facebook page and join in the conversation! It’s another way we can connect!)

  • Virtual Reality: VR environments are being explored as safe spaces to practice social skills and reduce anxiety around face-to-face interactions.
  • AI Assistants: Some researchers are developing AI tools to help autistic individuals interpret social cues or generate appropriate responses in conversations. AI can also help with random questions to ask to help continue conversations.
  • Video Modeling: Recording and reviewing conversations can be a powerful tool for developing social skills and understanding social dynamics. It can also help with practicing talking to strangers.

AI and other tools can help bridge the communications worlds and increase human interaction. The conversation around autism and social communication is evolving rapidly. As we move away from deficit-based models towards a neurodiversity paradigm, we’re beginning to recognize the richness and value of diverse communication styles. 

While challenges remain, the increasing awareness, technological advancements, and societal shifts towards inclusivity offer hope for a future where autistic individuals can more easily find their place in the social world.

The key lies in fostering mutual understanding and adaptation. By creating environments that accommodate diverse neurotypes, providing targeted support where needed, and celebrating the unique perspectives that autistic individuals bring to the table, we can build a society where everyone has the opportunity to engage in meaningful conversation and connection.

Speaking My Autism Mind

The art of human conversation can be a difficult one. Some are just born with the ability to effortlessly breeze through any conversation with anybody like it’s nothing, but unfortunately, many autistics struggle. It’s something I work on every day.

So, even if you weren’t born as a master conversationalist, you can improve and maybe even put a neurotypical person’s skills to shame!

I have never been the best conversationalist either, but I’m learning how to be an exemplar in it so I can bond better with the people around me and help others in my community do the same. If you choose to work on this (and it’s always a choice), you can master the art of conversation and any other skill you want, so remember that.

Additional Challenges Individuals with Autism Face

Learn more about other issues that autistics face:

Picture of Connor McClure

Connor McClure

I'm a young adult navigating life with autism. By sharing my experiences and views, I hope to create a better awareness, understanding, and compassion for those on the spectrum. Let's connect!
All Posts »