Yes, Yes! How Repeating Words (Palilalia) Achieves Better Language Processing

Repeating words or phrases after just saying them can often be a tool some use to assist with language processing.Most of us have listened to other individuals on the autism spectrum or with other neurological conditions repeating words or phrases, even if we didn’t understand why or even know it’s a rare speech disorder. It’s often portrayed with autistic characters in movies like Rain Man and The Accountant, for example. We might have challenges with autism speech patterns ourselves.

Speech and language for autism is often, but certainly not always, associated with challenges of repeating words. Palilalia is a type of verbal repetition that can occur in some individuals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). The term comes from the Greek words “palin” meaning again and “lalia” meaning speech or talk.

Words Up: So What Exactly is Palilalia?

Palilalia refers to the involuntary repetition of words, phrases, or sentences that were just spoken. This repetition often occurs immediately after the original utterance. For example, a person with palilalia might say “I want juice. I want juice. I want juice” in quick succession before being able to move on to a new thought or sentence.

Repeating words in palilalia are distinct from other types of repetitive speech. With echolalia, an individual repeats words or phrases spoken by someone else. Scripting involves the repetition of longer passages from movies, TV shows, books, etc. Stuttering is essentially repetitions of sounds or words typically at the beginning or middle of sentences or even prolonged vowel sounds at the start of the sounds (like attempting to say “shirt” and repeating the sound, “sh” several times.)

Palilalia is the automatic loop of one’s own recently spoken words.

Speech and Language for Autism and How Palilalia May Help Some Communicate

While palilalia can potentially occur with other developmental disabilities, neurological conditions like Tourette syndrome, and even in some typically developing children during language acquisition stages, it appears to be a co-occurring condition with some autistic individuals.

The reasons for the connection between autism and palilalia are not fully understood, but there are several theories about this:

Language Processing Deficits

Individuals with autism often have difficulties with auditory processing of language and integrating meanings rapidly. This could lead the brain to get “stuck” in a repetitive loop replaying the words or phrases until the full meaning of the “words up” alert is processed before moving on. 

Self-Stimulatory Behavior

Like other restricted and repetitive behaviors (RRBs) in autism, palilalia could be a self-stimulatory behavior that provides a desired sensation – in this case, an auditory input sensation from repeating the sounds and speech patterns. 

Coping Mechanism 

Palilalia may serve as a self-regulating coping strategy for some individuals with autism when feeling stressed, anxious, or overstimulated in their environment. The words up repetition could be calming by producing a familiar auditory pattern.

Restrictive/Repetitive Behaviors

The repetitive nature of palilalia aligns with one of the core characteristics of autism speech patterns – restrictive and repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, or activities (RRBs). The drive for sameness and repetition could contribute to involuntary speech repetitions.

Words Up: Managing Palilalia

For parents, caregivers, teachers, and therapists supporting individuals with autism who exhibit palilalia, there are some recommended strategies to help manage and minimize this behavior:

Use Visual Supports

Since auditory processing of language can be difficult, using visual tools like pictures, written words, schedules, and social stories can help reduce confusion and the perceived need for repeating words.

Respond with Clarity

When a person with palilalia repeats themselves multiple times, respond clearly and concisely once instead of repeating back their repetitions. This model moves forward in the conversation in a words up approach.

Don’t Call Excessive Attention

While palilalia can be socially inappropriate at times, drawing excessive attention or scolding usually does not help. Avoid shaming language and react as neutrally as possible.

Redirect Gently

Try redirecting to a new topic or activity calmly if repeating words persist excessively. A very slight change in discussion can break the loop.

Reduce Anxiety

For many with anxiety related to speech and language for autism, palilalia increases when feeling overstimulated, stressed, or anxious. Finding ways to provide a calming environment and sensory tools can alleviate anxiety that fuels repetitions.

Provide Outlets

Having appropriate therapeutic outlets for repetitive behaviors can help prevent inappropriate palilalia. Tools like fidget toys or audio repetition activities (songs, rhythmic speech) in therapy may satisfy that drive safely.

Speech Therapy

A speech-language pathologist can work directly on reducing problematic palilalia related to autism speech patterns through techniques like response interruption, redirection, modeling brief sentences, and more.

Promote Acceptance

At the end of the day, palilalia is a pattern of speech intimately connected to the neurological wiring of autism itself. While strategies to minimize it are helpful, fostering acceptance that it’s an aspect of autism prevents excessive shaming. With compassion and support, the impact can be lessened.

The Deeper Meaning of Palilalia vs Echolalia

Speech and language for autism can be enhanced with various strategies.While socially challenging, the presence of palilalia reveals important insights about speech and language for autism. The repetitive repetitions likely stem from multiple factors – auditory processing delays, self-regulating repetitive behaviors, language integration difficulties, and more. 

By studying palilalia, experts can gain a deeper understanding of autistic cognition and perception. Clinicians like Dr. Michelle Garcia Winner, a pioneer in the Social Thinking psychological treatment, view palilalia as a window into the experience of autism.

 “Those with palilalia are trying to rewire their brains. Their rewiring is evidenced in their repetitions,” she explains. The repetition of words and phrases provides an opportunity for the brain to reprocess language and integrate meanings through repetition.

The Spectrum of Palilalia and Repeating Words

It’s important to note that palilalia exists on a spectrum in autism, just as autism itself encompasses a wide range of abilities and characteristics. For some individuals, palilalia, as it relates to speech and language for autism, may only occur occasionally or in specific situations when they are stressed or overloaded with sensory input.

For others, palilalia can be persistent as autism speech patterns – with repetitions happening frequently throughout the day and potentially disrupting conversations and activities. The severity often depends on the individual’s auditory processing abilities, level of anxiety, and self-regulation skills.

Even within the same person, palilalia can fluctuate based on the situation, their emotional state, and how overwhelmed they feel in that moment. A calming, low-stress environment may result in minimal to no palilalia. But increased demands, noisy conditions, or general dysregulation can exacerbate repetitive speech.

Understanding this spectrum is key for parents, teachers, and therapists. What might seem excessive or rigid behavior is often the individual’s way of coping when their brain is overwhelmed and struggling to process language and auditory input efficiently in that instance.

The Role of Anxiety with Speech and Language for Autism

A major factor that can contribute to persistent and disruptive palilalia is anxiety. Many individuals on the autism spectrum experience issues with anxiety, whether generalized or specific situations that trigger the “fight-or-flight” response.

When the brain’s anxiety levels are high, it can exacerbate auditory processing difficulties as the person struggles to attend to and interpret language. This flood of anxiety creates a neurological logjam, resulting in the repetitive loop of palilalia as the brain tries to rhythmically regain control.

For some, palilalia vs. echolalia may even serve as a self-soothing mechanism during periods of heightened anxiety. The repetitive vocal patterns production of familiar speech shapes and sounds can be calming for an overwhelmed brain seeking sameness.

This connection between anxiety and palilalia highlights the importance of addressing anxiety management through words up strategies like:

– Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)

– Mindfulness and relaxation training

– Using calming sensory tools

– Avoiding overwhelming sensory environments

– Implementing clear routines and schedules

By learning to regulate anxiety more effectively, the neurological underpinnings of palilalia may be reduced – allowing for smoother auditory processing and conversational flow.

Palilalia vs Echolalia

Autism speech patterns, such as palilalia vs echolalia, can be managed with guidance from speech therapists and other professionals.As mentioned earlier, echolalia (repeating words spoken by others) is a distinct type of repetitive speech that is common in autism. However, for some individuals, palilalia and echolalia may be closely linked.

There are cases where a child’s initial repetitive speech is an echo of something said by someone else. But then the child continues echoing and looping that phrase repeatedly on their own – thus shifting into a bout of palilalia.

This transitional pattern provides clues about how echolalia and palilalia may stem from similar neurodevelopmental origins related to language processing, repetitive behaviors, and self-regulation through auditory repetition.

By improving functional speech and language for autism through therapies like speech therapy, Social Thinking, and others, both echolalia and palilalia can potentially be reduced over time. But this underscores that they are interwoven communicative patterns not easily disentangled for some individuals.

For many parents, one of the most challenging aspects of palilalia is the loss of reciprocal conversation. The continuous repeating words can feel like hitting a wall in the flow of dialogue. However, looking at it through a different lens, palilalia represents the person’s drive to understand and communicate – just with an added words up repetitive pattern.

With increased awareness, research, and therapies tailored around this core feature of autism, social disruptions can be minimized. Like other characteristics of autism, palilalia is not something that must be eliminated, but an aspect to understand and support with compassion.

Other Common Autistic Behaviors

There are many behaviors associated with having autism. Keep in mind that everyone presents differently, which is why it is caused by a spectrum disorder. However, there are common autism behaviors. Learn more about them. 

Picture of Connor McClure

Connor McClure

I'm a young adult navigating life with autism. By sharing my experiences and views, I hope to create a better awareness, understanding, and compassion for those on the spectrum. Let's connect!
All Posts »