The Gift of Understanding: Exchanging Presents Can Be Overwhelming
Choosing something for gift giving can be awkward for many people, neurotypicals included, because sometimes family members, friends, co-workers, and loved ones can be so hard to shop for.
There is also a struggle with exchanging presents because many people with autism just don’t know how to act when the spotlight turns on them and others watch while they self-consciously open a gift, regardless if it’s an item they actually want or not.
Many autistics struggle with the flat affect—or should I say neurotypical people struggle with it—because this affect makes autistics with the trait very hard to read.
That’s because many individuals on the spectrum often don’t show any emotion on their face or their body, so facial expressions and body language are nonexistent. There is nothing to “read” on them, so you can see how this can make receiving gifts a bit tricky.
Gift Exchanges Gaffes
A neurotypical may watch someone with autism showing no expression during the opening of gifts and think, “Does he like the gift?” “Does she hate it?” or “They literally just opened it and set it down, so I must have chosen poorly.” This can cause hurt feelings or a sense of disappointment or even anger when it happens.
However, the reality is more complicated. It’s not that autistics are unappreciative of gift giving, but the reality is that many individuals on the spectrum have a hard time expressing emotions. But, make no mistake, autistics very much experience them. After all, we’re not sociopaths; we’re just sometimes bad actors.
And the tricky part is that an autistic recipient of gift exchanges may actually love the present. It is just that sometimes it takes a while to sort through our emotions of how this new acquisition will fit into our often structured and ordered life. For example, if it’s a book, an individual with autism may wonder about when they will add reading to their schedule.
If it’s a new item of clothing, they may need to adjust to the sensation or determine when they want to wear it. Or where they will wear it, and for how long. And whether they will find the fabric comfortable or itchy. And so on.
Exchanging Presents: Why We Underreact
I have my own experience with an autistic opening of gifts situation, and looking back on it, I’m saddened I didn’t handle it better. But I was just a kid. I remember the time when I was celebrating my birthday with a party, and one of my friends got me a Hot Wheels race track. It was a cool gift, but the problem was I already had one.
I remember that I didn’t know why I felt bad about it at the time, because I couldn’t explain it logically, but now I know I was being rude. And my brain thought it was important enough for me to remember that moment all these years later. I bet many other people with autism can relate; so this is why we have to do better.
These social occasions that come with an abundance of expectations can feel overwhelming for autistic individuals. These celebratory occasions typically come with a complex symphony of emotions and sensory experiences.
What should be a time of joy and connection when exchanging presents often becomes a challenging navigation through unwritten social rules, sensory stimuli, and emotional minefields. When others want to embrace the connections, we sometimes simply want to retreat.
Understanding the Emotional Terrain of Opening of Gifts
Holidays and celebratory events are rarely just simple occasions. They’re intricate social events loaded with unspoken expectations, rapid emotional shifts, and sensory experiences that can quickly become overwhelming.
For autistic individuals, these gatherings represent a particularly challenging landscape of human interaction.
The traditional rituals of exchanging presents, family gatherings, formal meals, and social celebrations can trigger significant anxiety and emotional complexity.
Gift-giving, in particular, stands as a profound social ritual that goes far beyond the simple exchange of objects. It’s a deeply emotional transaction filled with nuanced expectations about emotional expression, gratitude, and social performance.
Many autistic individuals find themselves trapped in an internal struggle, trying to simultaneously process the physical gift, manage their genuine emotional response, and perform the socially expected reaction.
The Gift Exchanges Dilemma
Consider the moment a gift is handed to you. In that instant, your brain might be processing multiple simultaneous streams of information.
You’re assessing the physical object, interpreting the giver’s emotional state, attempting to regulate your own sensory and emotional response, and trying to construct an appropriate verbal and physical reaction. This is not a simple task—it’s a complex cognitive and emotional negotiation happening in milliseconds.
The performative aspect of gift receiving – the need to appear sufficiently excited, surprised, or grateful—can feel like an exhausting and inauthentic social script. And keep in mind that many autistics are not adept at masking their emotions when the gift falls short of the expectations.
Many autistic people report feeling intense pressure to manufacture an emotional response that matches what others expect. If a gift doesn’t align perfectly with their interests or sensory preferences, the struggle becomes even more pronounced.
The fear of appearing ungrateful, combined with the potential sensory discomfort of a new item, can create a perfect storm of internal tension.
This doesn’t mean autistic individuals don’t feel genuine appreciation. On the contrary, their gratitude can be deeply felt but expressed in ways that might not conform to neurotypical social expectations.
A carefully considered gift might be appreciated through careful examination, detailed questions about its origin, or a quiet, sincere acknowledgment. In other words, please don’t judge us for our initial reaction during the opening of gifts. Please!
Preparing for the Social Marathon
Preparation is the most powerful tool in managing holiday social interactions. This begins with honest, clear communication with family and close friends.
Consider having conversations well before the holiday events about your specific needs and challenges. This might involve discussing:
- Preferred gift types that align with your interests and sensory needs
- Potential modifications to gift-giving rituals that make you more comfortable
- Understanding that your emotional expression might look different from others when expressing gratitude
- Creating quiet spaces or escape routes during family gatherings
These conversations are not about demanding special treatment but about creating mutual understanding. Most loved ones genuinely want to make you feel comfortable and appreciated, even if they don’t immediately understand your unique perspective.
Another occasion where I was unable to fully appreciate an incredible gift, and acted unappreciative (even though I was actually overwhelmed), was when my parents surprised me with a car for my 16th birthday.
They had taken great pains to hide the car from me, and I was completely oblivious to the possibility I would be receiving my then-dream car of an orange Dodge Dart. But as we left a restaurant, there it was. And I honestly didn’t know what to do or say.
I’m not the type of guy who can feign excitement, but that was a time I wish I could have. Don’t get me wrong. It was an incredibly perfect present and one that I had actually dreamt about. But you sure wouldn’t have known that by seeing my emotionless gaze, all the while saying nothing.
Luckily, my parents “got” me and they understood. While they knew I was truly happy (and after I had time to process this new gift of my first step toward independence), I’m sure they had hoped for a little more enthusiasm when I was handed the keys.
Practical Strategies for Gift Exchanges and Expressing Gratitude
If unwrapping gifts in a group setting feels too intense, discuss the possibility of opening presents in a quieter, more private space. Many families are surprisingly understanding once the reasoning is explained. The goal is to create an environment that respects your sensory and emotional needs.
Some autistic individuals find great relief in more structured gift-giving approaches. This might mean:
- Creating detailed wish lists with specific items
- Suggesting gift cards or monetary gifts
- Requesting gifts that align closely with special interests
- Establishing clear gift-giving guidelines with family members
Managing Sensory Experiences
The holidays are a sensory minefield. Bright lights, loud noises, unfamiliar textures, and crowded spaces can quickly become overwhelming. Develop a personal sensory management strategy that might include:
- Noise-canceling headphones
- Comfortable, familiar clothing
- Stim toys or fidget tools
- A designated quiet space for decompression
- Planned breaks from social interactions
Your sensory comfort is paramount. It’s not rudeness to step away or manage your sensory needs – it’s essential self-care.
Personal Experiences and Individual Variations
While the previous guidance provides a framework, it’s crucial to understand that autism is a spectrum, and no two autistic individuals experience holidays, gift-giving, or social interactions exactly the same way.
Some might find immense joy in carefully selected gifts that align with their special interests, while others might experience profound anxiety about the entire scenario around exchanging presents.
The texture of wrapping paper, the sound of tearing it open, the unexpected smell of new clothing or electronics – these can trigger sensory overwhelm that neurotypical family members might not comprehend. And our unique way of expressing gratitude may take it to a whole new level!
Family dynamics add another layer of complexity. Relatives who don’t understand neurodiversity might misinterpret an autistic person’s genuine reaction as rudeness or lack of appreciation.
This misunderstanding can create years of emotional tension and miscommunication. Education becomes key – not just for the autistic individual, but for the entire family system.
Technology and Gift-Giving
In our increasingly digital world, technology offers unique opportunities for autistic individuals to manage holiday gift exchanges. Online wish lists, direct digital gifts, and clear communication platforms can provide structured, predictable ways of navigating these social interactions.
Virtual gift exchanges or pre-discussed gift protocols can reduce spontaneity-related anxiety. Some families find success in adopting more transparent gift-giving strategies, where recipients have a clearer idea of what to expect. This might involve shared spreadsheets, direct conversations about preferences, or even collaborative gift selection processes.
Emotional Regulation and Self-Advocacy
Developing emotional regulation skills becomes crucial during high-stress social periods like holidays. This doesn’t mean suppressing your authentic feelings, but rather understanding and managing your emotional responses.
Consider working with a therapist or counselor who specializes in neurodivergent experiences to develop personalized coping strategies.
Self-advocacy is a powerful tool. This means being able to clearly communicate your needs, set boundaries, and explain your perspective. It’s not about making demands, but about creating mutual understanding.
Phrases like “I appreciate your thoughtfulness, and to help me fully enjoy this gift, could you tell me more about why you selected it?” can transform potentially stressful interactions into meaningful connections and effective ways of expressing gratitude.
Cultural and Generational Perspectives
Autistic individuals might find certain cultural practices more or less challenging depending on their specific sensory and social processing strengths.
Generational differences also play a significant role. Older family members might have less understanding of neurodiversity, while younger generations are often more informed and adaptable.
Creating intergenerational dialogue about autism and individual differences can help bridge potential communication gaps.
Beyond the Gift: Valuing Connection
Ultimately, the holiday season is about connection, not perfect performance. For autistic individuals, connection might look different from traditional expectations. It could mean:
- Sharing a special interest
- Engaging in a quiet, focused activity together
- Creating predictable, comfortable interaction spaces
- Acknowledging each other’s unique way of experiencing the world
Reframing Expectations
Perhaps the most crucial aspect of navigating holiday interactions is reframing expectations – both for yourself and for others. Your worth is not determined by how perfectly you perform social rituals. Your authentic self is valuable exactly as you are.
This means giving yourself permission to:
- Not enjoy every moment of holiday celebrations
- Express gratitude in your own unique way
- Prioritize your emotional and sensory well-being
- Set clear boundaries
- Communicate your needs clearly and without apology
The Gift of Understanding
Ultimately, the most meaningful gift during the holidays is understanding. This applies both to how others understand you and how you understand yourself. Recognize that your way of experiencing the world is not a deficit, but a different and valuable perspective.
The holidays can be a time of genuine connection. This might look different for each autistic individual. For some, it might mean sharing a special interest, enjoying a quiet moment together, or simply being present in a way that feels comfortable and authentic.
Embracing Your Unique Experience
As you move through the holiday season, remember that your experiences are valid. The challenges you face are real, and your strategies for managing them are important. You don’t need to conform to anyone else’s definition of how to celebrate or express joy.
Your neurodivergent perspective is a gift – not just during the holidays, but every day. The depth of your thinking, the intensity of your interests, and the authenticity of your emotional experience are profound strengths.
This holiday season, be gentle with yourself. Create space for your needs. Communicate your boundaries. And most importantly, recognize that you are worthy of love, respect, and understanding, exactly as you are.
The holiday landscape might be complex, but you have the strength, creativity, and resilience to navigate it on your own terms.
Common Autistic Behaviors
There are many behaviors associated with having autism. Keep in mind that everyone presents differently, which is why it is called a spectrum disorder. However, there are common autism behaviors. Learn more about them.
- Autism and Eye Rolling: Why It’s Odd, But Perfectly Okay
- Eye Contact Avoidance: 8 Best Ways to See Eye to Eye
- Staring Meaning: Unlocking the Secrets of Intense Gazes
- Autism Elopement: Why Wandering Off Is A Behavioral Nightmare
- Autism and Sleep Disorders: Top 4 Reason for Sleepless Nights
- Crowds Phobia and Autism: How to Tame Anxiety Overload
- How Repeating Words (Palilalia) Achieves Better Language Processing
- Autism and ADHD: Making Sense of the Overlap
- Autism Masking & Code Switching: How to Redefine Acceptance
- Autistic Stimming Behaviors: Why We Do and How It’s Important
- OCD and Autism: Could You Have One Condition or Both?
